Hey YouTube: Bring Back the Music

Mashable broke a story yesterday about how YouTube is muting videos that contain uncopyrighted music.

I get it. Just as Pandora pays for music streams, YouTube should pay a licensing fee when music is streamed from its site. YouTube makes money from ads posted on pages that visit and some of that money should go to artists and copyright holders if their licensed works are being used.

But there has to be a better way then just pressing mute. YouTube is obviously using a digital fingerprinting technology to match songs that stream on its site against a database of copyrighted works, so it knows what songs are playing and how often. Why couldn’t it just take it one step further? There are standing agreements on paying for streamed music. Webcasters pay them already. Why can’t YouTube calculate the rates and figure out a monetization scheme that works for them?

They are inserting ads into videos already and could crank those up. Or they could do what MySpace did and sell downloads as part of their mix. Come on Google: strike a deal with Amazon; align yourself with iTunes; work with the labels directly. Do something other than press mute.

Maybe this is just a bargaining ploy. I am sure Google/YouTube is in talks with the labels. Or maybe they are waiting out the negotiations of webcaster rates, but can’t you get someone at Google Labs to cook up a solution?

Wonder how this will affect you? Stan Schroeder at Mashable talks about some of the “stupid” implications of silencing songs on YouTube.

1. No more RickRoll (or any other authentic viral videos with copyrighted music)

2. No more anime music videos

3. No more movie remixes (I’ll add to this: no more “here’s a song from a movie that doesn’t have a video of its own so I will post it for people to find and listen to it.”)

4. No more Guitar Hero/Rock Band videos

5. No more dance videos

Update: Here’s YouTube’s explanation for their move. What do you think?

(Full disclosure: musicFIRST is a client for my day job. They are weighing in on establishing a performance right for songs when they play on the radio – currently artists don’t get paid for song play on the radio. The issue is separate from YouTube, streaming, etc. I am not representing them with this post. These are my personal views.)


~ by montelutz on January 15, 2009.

One Response to “Hey YouTube: Bring Back the Music”

  1. If you bump into a muted video on youtube, post this comment:

    ‘We love music! We can’t stand by silently while the music industry continues its decades-long effort to lock up our culture! If you think that it sucks that audio had to be disabled here BOYCOTT MUSIC INDUSTRY!

    – Only buy audio-cds second-hand from now on (Use amazon’s second-hand section or ebay from apparently private persons)

    – Don’t download from online music stores anymore

    – Support self-marketing bands

    – Spread this message here on every muted video you encounter’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: